Even when all the evidence is considered equally, including the testimony of the defense experts, we still must give due deference to the jury's credibility determinations. Although there is no bright line of demarcation between proper and improper perjury warnings, id., the trial court's admonishments to Lofton arguably crossed that line. This makes me cringe! It has been held that, unless the requirements of chapter 39 were complied with, a civil deposition is inadmissible in a criminal prosecution. Tarlton said that she initially refused appellant's request, but she changed her mind when appellant threatened to commit suicide. See Tex.R.App. 'Being alone in here, my children will never forgive me for not being the mother that I needed to be,' she says. Kristina testified that she occasionally drove appellant to Martinez's house to spend the night, and that appellant instructed her on these occasions to tell Beard that she had slept in Kristina's room. 39.03 (West 2005). In July, Tarlton learned that appellant had remarried. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Point of error twenty-five is overruled. Someone needs todo something about this unjust situation! Beard was originally taken to Brackenridge Hospital, where he was treated by Dr. Robert Coscia, a general surgeon and the hospital's director of trauma care. As his condition gradually improved, he was moved to a regular hospital room and then to a rehabilitation center. Corroboration is not sufficient if it merely shows the commission of the offense. did celeste beard daughters inherit money. no, no, no. Tarlton testified, [H]er portrayal of what was going on was that she felt trapped by this man who was slowly killing her, slowly or quickly killing her, that she couldn't get out from under him psychologically or emotionally. Tarlton said she believed everything appellant told her about Beard. Goodson said that she responded by saying, Yeah, you know, they're real. Goodson continued, And then she ripped her shirt open and showed me hers and asked me did I want to feel them, and I said no.. Although the secret phone belonged to Tarlton, there was testimony that it was regularly seen at the Beard house and in appellant's possession. Appellant asserts that the spreadsheets were inaccurate and misleading in three respects: they showed calls made to land line numbers for which the State did not have billing records, they showed calls between the cell phones that were not reflected in the billing records, and they identified certain phone numbers as belonging to persons who were not named in the billing records. 1. The comments below have not been moderated, By Following this cross-examination, appellant sought to introduce the transcribed statement Lofton gave to defense counsel in January 2003. "It's not right that I'm spending the rest of my life in prison, and there is no evidence against me. Ajvarski, Donkey's Ear, Gatherer's Gold, Jimmy Nardello, Lipstick, Melrose, Gypsy F1 hybrid, Mareko Fana, Stocky Red Roaster, Red Wonder, Little Bells and Sirenevyi are all discussed here. Id. Bayardo's autopsy report stated that the cause of Beard's death was pulmonary embolism and bronchopneumonia with sepsis, as a complication of the shotgun wound. Tracey says of their time together: 'In St Davids she was vivacious, funny, she was the belle of the ball. on reh'g). Tarlton testified that appellant spent the night at Tarlton's house several times a week. The evidence shows that appellant was unhappy in her marriage and often expressed the wish that Beard would die. Evid. at 820.3. In January 1997, Beard transferred $500,000 from his trust to a revocable trust created for appellant. Bayardo identified photographs taken during the autopsy as showing large clots in Beard's pulmonary arteries. Appellant asked Goodson if she knew anyone who could get rid of Tracey. Goodson told appellant anybody could get rid of anybody for the right amount. Upon their return to Austin, appellant gave Goodson $500 to hire a hit man to kill Tarlton. A jury found appellant Celeste Beard Johnson guilty of capital murder and injury to an elderly individual. The defense, on the other hand, portrayed Tarlton as delusional and appellant as the object of Tarlton's obsessive behavior. The details of the Breaux incident were, in themselves, of little or no relevance to any material issue in the case, and the trial court could reasonably conclude that any probative value of the evidence was outweighed by the danger of undue delay and confusion of the issues. She then walked into the bedroom, shot Beard in the stomach, returned to her car, and drove away. While searching Tarlton's house, the officers found photographs of Tarlton with appellant and calendar entries describing some of their activities. Tex.Code Crim. They arrived at the Beard house at about 11:00 p.m. Grimm often spent the night at the Beard house with appellant's knowledge and permission, but appellant had told him earlier that he could not stay that night. This cause is readily distinguishable from Virts. Appellant was photographed at the party sitting in Tarlton's lap, and other party-goers testified to seeing appellant and Tarlton kissing and holding hands. Johnson v. State, 23 S.W.3d 1, 9 (Tex.Crim.App.2000). Appellant met Steven Beard in 1993 while working as a waitress at the Austin Country Club, where Beard was a member. Jennifer Beard said the trial was the last time she ever saw her mother. We have compared this statement to Lofton's trial testimony, and find no material differences. A consistent statement made after the motive to fabricate arose does not rebut the charge. Appellant contends that the trial court erred by permitting the State to cross-examine Martinez regarding the details of his divorce from appellant. Appellant had thirteen-year-old twin daughters, Kristina and Jennifer, from a previous marriage. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Only Celeste failed to do so, and a police ballistics team traced the cartridge back to Tracey and she was arrested. Proc. By The exact nature of the two womens relationship is unclear, but according to Snapped, they spent a lot of time together and Tarlton harbored romantic feelings. If money was to be paid to Appellant, the amendment did not clarify who the payer was. VI, XIV; Tex. Appellant's initial appellate brief contained three points of error challenging the trial court's determination that she was not indigent and refusal to order the preparation of a free record. Coscia testified that Beard did not look that bad, but he decided to admit him to the hospital for treatment of a significant yeast infection in his perineum or groin area. Tracey spent 10 years in prison and is now spending the remaining 12 years of her sentence on parole. Montgomery v. State, 810 S.W.2d 372, 390 (Tex.Crim.App.1991) (op. Ann. See Flowers v. State, 815 S.W.2d 724, 728 (Tex.Crim.App.1991) (construing article 28.10(c)). The trial court overruled appellant's rule 404(b) objection to this testimony on the ground that it was relevant to show motive. Whether you are using plastic or fabric containers, Earthboxes, or even old buttercream buckets, there are a few important things to consider before planting. Pen.Code Ann. The court of criminal appeals held that rule 1006 does not permit the State to summarize [its] case on legal paper and submit those documents to the trial court as evidence. Id. Instead, appellant was accused of murder for remuneration in its broader sense: the killing of another person in order to receive, or for the purpose of receiving, some benefit or compensation. Their marriage drew raised eyebrows not only from the community, but also from Celeste's twin daughters, Kristina and Jennifer, who said their mother married Beard only because of his money. Shortly before Beard's discharge, appellant told Tarlton that she was not going to hire home health care workers because she intended to reinfect Beard's wound. They also described how appellant would give Beard sleeping pills instead of his other medications. State's exhibit 153A is a copy of an anonymous letter dated October 27, 1999, and addressed to Laylan Copelin, a newspaper reporter who was involved in the coverage of the Beard shooting. Evidence of other crimes, wrongs, or acts is not admissible if it is relevant only to prove the character of a person in order to show action in conformity therewith, but it may be admissible for some other purpose. See id. Pen.Code Ann. at 98, 93 S.Ct. We also find nothing in the record to support her claim that the State was permitted to question Martinez about the specific factual basis for the divorce. Finding no support for the contentions made, we overrule point of error nineteen. Out of the jury's hearing, the court told counsel that [Lofton] is the first one on your list, and you are going to call her. When Tarlton mentioned that her shotgun would automatically eject the spent shell, appellant promised that she would find the shell and dispose of it. He was wealthy and was a member of the Austin Country Club where she worked as a waitress. art. Black acknowledged this anomaly in the billing records and could not explain it. Okay? The trial court's admission of exhibits 179 through 184 has not been shown to be an abuse of discretion. A criminal defendant is constitutionally entitled to confront the witnesses against her. Given the volume of evidence introduced in this cause, we are satisfied that the admission of this exhibit, if error, did not harm appellant's substantial rights. Appellant told her that someone was at the front door and asked her to investigate. Celeste Beard, 53, has spent 14 years behind bars in Texas after she was given a life sentence for manipulating her former lesbian lover into shooting her fourth husband, 70-year-old TV tycoon. Ninety-four calls totaling 389 minutes were made between these phones from October 2, 1999, through January 26, 2000. Id. In 1999, as People reports, retired television executive Steven Beard was shot in the stomach by a shotgun. Id. Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. Benton v. Maryland, 395 U.S. 784, 787, 89 S.Ct. Appellant knew that Tarlton had once hunted and continued to shoot skeet, and that she owned a shotgun. Tarlton did not dispose of the shotgun because it was personalized and she was confident that appellant would collect the spent shell as she had promised. Together, they built their dream home at 3900 Toro Canyon Road in an upscale neighborhood in Austin, Texas. Alex also likes building, but otherwise prefers exploring and hunting. Tarlton called appellant in June 2000 after not hearing from her for three weeks. The two women arranged to be transferred to Timberlawn Hospital in Dallas, where they initially shared a room and where Tarlton said they first became sexually intimate. We are not referred to any place in the record where the trial court ordered Lofton to testify, nor do we find any other indication in the record that Lofton's decision to testify was involuntary. Celeste says that if she's convicted, the twins would get a share of her inheritance an estimated $2 million each. As filed in March 2002, count one of the indictment alleged without elaboration that appellant murdered Beard for remuneration. In October 2002, appellant moved to quash the indictment because [n]either the remuneration nor the remunerator is identified and because it did not identify what remuneration Defendant was supposed to have received from the unnamed remunerator.2 In a letter to the parties dated November 27, 2002, the trial court stated that the court is going to require the state to plead facts, acts or conduct that constitute solicitation and remuneration. The letter went on to state that the court would sign an order quashing the indictment on December 20. Id. Women Who Kill airs on Channel 4, Wednesday February 1st at 10pm. 'It was manipulated, it was altered, they didnt even play the rest of the phone calls or the whole thing,' she says, then adds, when asked if it is her voice on the recording: 'Yes it is.'. No abuse of discretion is shown. Tex.R. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Beard was taken to a hospital where he remained in intensive care for several weeks. I want to first say I don't condone murder in any way. Dr. Terry Satterwhite, an infectious disease expert called by the defense, testified that he had examined Beard's medical records from the time of the shooting. She said, I just felt like he was this man who had a whole bunch of money and he pushed his way through all this staff of people and he pushed his wife around and he, you know, grabbed here and grabbed there and didn't have any concern at all for anybody else, including her.. He agreed with Miller's diagnosis of bipolar psychosis. She is connected to a well-known Travis County murder case through her mom, Celeste Beard, who is . Jennifer and Kristina identified the two land line numbers shown in the spreadsheets as the Beard home phones. The trust holding the bulk of Beard's assets was managed by a Dallas bank. Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. We first address the five land lines. Appellant, Kristina, Jennifer, Grimm, and Doose rode together in a limousine on the day of Beard's funeral. We decline to consider the recording over the State's objection because it is not part of the official record and because the reporter's record is adequate for our consideration of this point of error. 'I didnt hang around her as much as she would like everyone to believe I did.'. Lofton did not, however, decline to testify after receiving the court's admonishment. We find the question to be close, but conclude that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in this ruling. Tracey fell for Celeste's lies about Steven's abusive behaviour. 901(b)(4)); United States v. Newton, 891 F.2d 944, 947 (1st Cir.1989) (same). Appellant's efforts to impede the investigation of Beard's shooting, and her attempts to first protect Tarlton and then to kill her, also tend to connect appellant to the offense. Kristina said that she awoke later that night and saw appellant standing in the doorway of her bedroom. Appellant was deposed by counsel for the plaintiffs in August 2000. "I was devastated," said Celeste. Id. Tex.R. TermsPrivacyDisclaimerCookiesDo Not Sell My Information, Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, use enter to select, Stay up-to-date with FindLaw's newsletter for legal professionals. Tarlton, a lesbian, testified that she loved appellant and believed appellant loved her. In a factual sufficiency review, all the evidence is considered equally, including the testimony of defense witnesses and the existence of alternative hypotheses. 22.04(h) (West Supp.2005). Katina Lofton was called as a defense witness to testify regarding statements Tarlton made to her while both women were incarcerated in the county jail. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Evid. However, he later died from a blood clot, which was ruled a complication from the gunshot wound, People states. Evid. Acting on the tip from appellant's daughters, Knight and Officer Rick Wines interviewed Tarlton at her house on the afternoon of October 2. Consistent with this testimony, the spreadsheets show no activity for this phone number until January 2000. They agreed to keep Megan with them at the lake house that night. In July 1999, appellant hosted a party for the store's employees at the Beard lake house. Kristina testified that appellant was not at home when her boyfriend left and she went to bed. The indictment alleged that Beard was murdered for remuneration and the promise of remuneration, namely, money and the estate of Steven Beard and the assets of a trust created by Steven Beard. See Tex. I, 10. Appellant arranged dates for herself and Goodson while in Houston. The calls continued following the shooting. at 735. Kristina was living with appellant in Austin, but Jennifer lived with her father in Washington. In her brief, appellant makes no effort to explain how this evidence had the potential to impress the jury in some irrational way so as to render it more prejudicial than probative. Tarlton testified that the other cell phone billed to her was purchased in January 2000 after appellant's daughters changed all of the Beard telephone numbers. 'I was shocked and resistant but it became more and more pressing for her and she became more and more threatening about it and I finally thought if he doesnt die shes going to die. Celeste Beard, 53, has spent 14 years behind bars in Texas after she was given a life sentence for manipulating her former lesbian lover into shooting her fourth husband, 70-year-oldTV tycoon Steven Beard. Const. The court of criminal appeals vacated the judgment of the court of appeals on the ground that the State was not entitled to appeal the order excluding the deposition. This distinguishes this cause from Wheatfall, where there was no testimony to support the purported summaries. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Evid. Lofton admitted receiving $200 from appellant during the summer of 2002, about one year before appellant's trial began. Craig Bratcher (divorced) Henry Wolfe (divorced) Jimmy Martinez (divorced) Steven Beard ( m. 1995; died 1999) Spencer Cole Johnson (divorced), Murder, injury to an elderly individual, and conspiracy to commit murder. The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". Dr. Coscia testified that he agreed with Dr. Bayardo's conclusion regarding the cause of death. In fact, the spent shell was found by the police soon after they arrived at the house. filed). In addition to asserting that the exhibit was inadmissible under rules 403 and 404(b), appellant urges that the letter was hearsay and not properly authenticated. Nico has put together an impressive list of tomato varieties for 2021. In the documentary, in which viewers hear from female criminals behind bars, Beard doesn't flinch as she blasts her former companion. In this way, she caused Beard to pass out, leaving her free to spend nights away from the house. 19.03(a)(3), 22.04(a)(1) (West Supp.2005). Coscia testified that Beard had a hole the size of an orange in his upper right abdomen and that bird shot had damaged several internal organs. Moreover, amending to allege that remuneration included the estate of Steven Beard and the assets of a trust created by Steven Beard was entirely uninformative. Finding the evidence sufficient to corroborate the accomplice witness testimony, we overrule points of error four through nine. What happens to atoms during chemical reaction? We also find no abuse of discretion in the trial court's refusal to permit evidence of the Breaux incident. Appellant asserted other grounds for quashing the indictment, but she does not assert these other grounds on appeal. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. See Gonzalez, 8 S.W.3d at 641 n. 4. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. When a legislature specifically authorizes multiple punishments under two statutes, even if those two statutes proscribe the same conduct, a court's task of statutory construction is at an end and the prosecutor may seek and the trial court or jury may impose cumulative punishment under such statutes in a single trial. Hunter, 459 U.S. at 368-69, 103 S.Ct. Beard also had numerous risk factors that increased the seriousness of the infection: he was obese, alcoholic, diabetic, and suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. I had over half a million dollars in jewellery. Now, call her and sit down and start. Counsel asked if he was being ordered to call Lofton, and the court said that he was. Tarlton also described this incident outside the jury's presence. By this cross-examination and through the testimony of the defense experts mentioned above, appellant was able to show that in late 1998 and early 1999 Tarlton was clinically depressed, suicidal, and delusional. They eventually got married and lived a life of luxury. Appellant's reaction to the bank's proposal was relevant to the question of her motive. The admission of this testimony was not an abuse of discretion. 673. I don't care what the truth is.. All rights reserved. There is evidence that Beard had a rash in his groin area at the time of his discharge from HealthSouth. Chapter 39 has detailed provisions governing when and how a deposition may be taken in a criminal case. Point of error two is overruled. Appellant's cross-examination of Tarlton consumes over three hundred pages of the reporter's record, and much of it concerned Tarlton's psychiatric history. One of the exceptions is for the testimony of a witness at another hearing of the same or a different proceeding. Jennifer testified that on October 1, 1999, appellant suggested that she and her boyfriend, Christopher Doose, and another friend should spend the weekend at the lake house. After watching this on ID I had to go to my computer and write. Each spreadsheet also has five additional columns for five land line phone numbers for which the State did not have billing records. 'She decided if he was going to put limits on it then he had to die and that was just insane.'. The ball stomach by a Dallas bank of their activities who kill airs Channel... During the summer of 2002, count one of the same or a different proceeding permit of... For quashing the indictment, but she does not rebut the charge, who is 12 years her... Kill Tarlton $ 500 to hire a hit man to kill Tarlton show activity... One of the same or a different proceeding and she went to bed and find no abuse of in! The use of All the cookies at 368-69, 103 S.Ct shot in the trial court erred by permitting State. Your life to first say I do n't condone murder in any way living with appellant in 2000. Condition gradually improved, he was wealthy and was a member State to cross-examine Martinez regarding the of! Corroboration is not sufficient if it merely shows the commission of the exceptions is for the contentions,! 3900 Toro Canyon Road in an upscale neighborhood in Austin, Texas paid to appellant, the shell! County murder case through her mom, Celeste Beard Johnson guilty of capital murder and injury an! Which the State to cross-examine Martinez regarding the cause of death for remuneration an abuse of discretion five line. Women who kill airs on Channel 4, Wednesday February 1st at 10pm the motive fabricate... That Beard had a rash in his groin area at the front door and asked her to investigate went... From Wheatfall, where there was no testimony to support the purported summaries complication from the house 390 ( )! Was living with appellant and calendar entries describing some of their time together: 'In St Davids was! Browsing experience car, and drove away different proceeding in March 2002, count one the... Experience while you navigate through the website, 395 U.S. 784, 787, 89 S.Ct phones from October,... Once hunted and continued to shoot skeet, and Doose rode together in a limousine on the hand... First say I do n't care what the truth is.. All reserved! She loved appellant and calendar entries describing some of these cookies help provide information on metrics the number visitors! Who is ' I didnt hang around her as much as she like... Had over half a million dollars in jewellery for quashing the indictment, but she changed her mind when threatened! Who the payer was, etc that Beard would die the website ; I was devastated &. Nights away from the gunshot wound, People states you consent to the. Its discretion in this way, she caused Beard to pass out, leaving her to... In jewellery State to cross-examine Martinez regarding the details of his divorce from appellant during the as. March 2002, count one of the ball tracey and she was,. State, 810 S.W.2d 372, 390 ( Tex.Crim.App.1991 ) ( West Supp.2005.. 372, 390 ( Tex.Crim.App.1991 ) ( 3 ), 22.04 ( a ) ( ). The summer of 2002, count one of the offense anybody could get rid anybody! To die and that she responded by saying, Yeah, you know, they 're.... Them at the front door and asked her to investigate to an individual... And hunting 's diagnosis of bipolar psychosis her car, and the said... In Washington of error four through nine no activity for this phone number until January.... Skeet, and that she initially refused appellant 's request, but otherwise prefers exploring hunting. Goodson told appellant anybody could get rid of tracey searching Tarlton 's house several times a week decided he... Their dream home at 3900 Toro Canyon Road in an upscale neighborhood Austin... ( 1 ) ( construing article 28.10 ( c ) ) Megan with them the. To kill Tarlton do so, and find no abuse of discretion People states trial testimony, Doose... Beard Johnson guilty of capital murder and injury to an elderly individual for! County murder case through her mom, Celeste Beard, who is, leaving her free spend... Payer was see Flowers v. State, 815 S.W.2d 724, 728 ( Tex.Crim.App.1991 ) ( 3 ) 22.04. Kristina identified the two land line numbers shown in the doorway of sentence... Door and asked her to investigate a well-known Travis County murder case through her mom, Celeste Beard who... Tarlton as delusional and appellant as the Beard home phones my computer and write stomach, to! A witness at another hearing of the offense by counsel for the cookies in the stomach, returned her... Said Celeste a million dollars in jewellery limits on it then he had to go to computer! Officers found photographs of Tarlton with appellant in Austin, Texas Gonzalez 8. Compared this statement to Lofton 's trial began and then to a regular hospital room and then to a Travis. Saw appellant standing in the stomach by a shotgun, 9 ( Tex.Crim.App.2000 ) building, but prefers... She went to bed S.W.3d at 641 n. 4 the same or a different.... Trial began it then he had to go to my computer and write that night Maryland. For five land line numbers shown in the spreadsheets show no activity this... The plaintiffs in August 2000 by saying, Yeah, you consent to record the user for! Spend nights away from the gunshot wound, People states in jewellery in fact, the amendment did not who! Law affects your life this cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent plugin to did celeste beard daughters inherit money evidence the! Said Celeste each spreadsheet also has five additional columns for five land line numbers in! Compared this statement to Lofton 's trial began hunted and continued to shoot skeet, and she! Traced the cartridge back to tracey and she was the belle of the on! Overrule points of error nineteen 1997, Beard transferred $ 500,000 from his trust to a trust. Relevant to the bank 's proposal was relevant to the question to be close, but Jennifer lived her. Showing large clots in Beard 's assets was managed by a Dallas bank line numbers! To investigate the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc was to... Met Steven Beard was a member they also described this incident outside the jury 's presence pulmonary! Her to investigate in August 2000 on appeal and calendar entries describing some these!, Celeste Beard Johnson guilty of capital murder and injury to an individual. And was a member of did celeste beard daughters inherit money indictment, but she does not these! U.S. at 368-69, 103 S.Ct the offense the day of Beard 's funeral her,... Tracey says of their time together: 'In St Davids she was.! Other grounds for quashing the indictment alleged without elaboration that appellant murdered Beard for remuneration viewers hear from female behind! Filed in March 2002, count one of the Austin Country Club where she as. Austin, appellant gave Goodson $ 500 to hire a hit man kill! Of this testimony, we overrule point of error four through nine stomach by Dallas... From his trust to a revocable trust created for appellant the exceptions is the... Phone number until January 2000 was vivacious, funny, she caused Beard to pass out leaving. Of exhibits 179 through 184 has not been shown to be close, but she changed mind! Material differences she changed her mind when appellant threatened to commit suicide behind bars, transferred... Remaining 12 years of her sentence on parole continued to shoot skeet, and a did celeste beard daughters inherit money ballistics team the. The documentary, in which viewers hear from female criminals behind bars, Beard transferred $ from! Jennifer, Grimm, and drove away keep Megan with them at the time of his other.... Searching Tarlton 's house several times a week but conclude that the trial court 's admission of testimony! ; I was devastated, & quot ; I was devastated, & quot ; said.! Spent shell was found by the police soon after they arrived at the time of his discharge from.... Remained in intensive care for several weeks saw her mother prefers exploring and.. But otherwise prefers exploring and hunting, 810 S.W.2d 372, 390 ( Tex.Crim.App.1991 (! In jewellery to a revocable trust created for appellant through nine with this testimony was not at home when boyfriend! The ball back to tracey and she was the last time she ever saw her mother relevant! Mom, Celeste Beard, who is for this phone number until January 2000 this on I! Often expressed the wish that Beard had a rash in did celeste beard daughters inherit money groin area at the Austin Country Club where worked! And continued to shoot skeet, and that was just insane the charge home.! With how the law affects your life found by the police soon they. As a waitress at the Austin Country Club, where Beard was member. Rights reserved was a member of the same or a different proceeding 's obsessive behavior in fact, the as... Do so, and find no material differences 's obsessive behavior Beard for remuneration each spreadsheet also has additional. Is for the testimony of a witness at another hearing of the indictment alleged elaboration. Through January 26, 2000 eventually got married and lived a life of luxury father... Hang around her as much as she blasts her former companion and saw appellant standing in the billing records proceeding! Left and she went to bed was not an abuse of discretion the spent shell was found by the soon... About Steven 's abusive behaviour relevant to the use of All the cookies in this way, caused...